History Class, Music, Uncategorized, World War 2, World War I

Musical Interlude: “I’ll Be Home for Christmas”

Bing Crosby, stage, screen and radio star, sings to Allied troops at the opening of the London stage door canteen in Piccadilly, London, England.” Pearson, August 31, 1944. 111-SC-193249.
Source: NARA World War II Photos – ARC Identifier: 531210 Image courtesy of Wikimedia Commons

Every year, the day after Thanksgiving brings changes in the Clare household. First the furniture must all shift to accommodate the Christmas tree. Mr. Clare and I set it up while engaging in the annual “how did all of these lights burn out?” discussion. Then, out come the ornaments and the Advent calendar with its countdown to Christmas. The children gather evergreen and holly from our yard to construct an Advent wreath, and I trim the greenery down so that it won’t catch fire from the Advent candles when it starts to dry out. Over all of the bustle is the sound that we’ve been waiting for—the sound of Christmas music.

Since his hanger broke, Captain Kirk has transferred from being a tree ornament to watching over a portion of our Christmas music collection.

From carols to crooners to country western, (that’s the influence of my husband’s side of the family) we’ve amassed quite a collection of Christmas music, both sacred and secular. There’s something about these melodies, no matter how many years pass—they create a unique seasonal soundtrack that melds memories of the past with hope for the future.

Christmas music has its own place in history—I think of soldiers on opposite sides of the battlefields in WWI singing together during the famous Christmas truce. While I’ve not found any stories of similar wide-spread good will during WWII, music was still an important factor in morale, both for those serving and for those waiting for their loved ones to return home.

One song that played a part in WWII history is recorded on the album that I’m currently listening to.

Christmas of 1943 came to a world in turmoil. Families and friends were separated. Loved ones were unable to travel home for the holidays. Fear and uncertainty swirled around muddled reports of current events. (Sound familiar?)

The war in Europe had begun over four years earlier. Hostilities in the Pacific had been going on even longer between Japan and China. After the Pearl Harbor attack in 1941, the U.S. had fully committed to the Allied cause. By 1943, over 9 million men (and quite a few women, including members of the Army nurse corps) were serving their country on land, sea, and in the air. (Stop by the National WWII Museum’s site for a more detailed break down.)

It was to this world that composer Walter Kent and lyricist James “Kim” Gannon introduced a new song, a song that encapsulated the nostalgic longing many people were feeling. It was titled, “I’ll Be Home for Christmas.”

According to some sources, the nostalgia evoked by the song almost kept it from being recorded. Reportedly, producers felt the song was too sad and it took Bing Crosby’s endorsement of the tune to get it recorded.

It seems that the American public agreed with Mr. Crosby rather than the naysayers. He recorded the song in October of 1943. In spite of its rather melancholy ending, “I’ll Be Home For Christmas” caught on almost immediately and quickly rose through the charts. It peaked at #3, and earned Crosby his 5th golden record. As far as its impact on the war, the Library of Congress says:

 “I’ll Be Home for Christmas” became the most requested song at Christmas U.S.O. shows in both Europe and the Pacific and Yank, the GI magazine, said Crosby accomplished more for military morale than anyone else of that era.

From the article: I’ll Be Home for Christmas
. Library of Congress, Washington, DC, 2002

“I’ll Be Home For Christmas” and Crosby’s big hit from the previous year “White Christmas” were released on V-disc in 1945. Interestingly enough, in spite of the popularity with American listeners, “I’ll Be Home for Christmas” was banned by the BBC during the war, because they felt that its “sickly sentimentality” was bad for morale.

Sentimental it may be, but I still like Bing, and his recording is a standard in our household. What about you?

Below is a video of “I’ll Be Home for Christmas,” set to a background of colorized photos from the era.

Whether you’ll be home for this Christmas or not, I’m wishing you one full of joy, good health, and peace.

23 thoughts on “Musical Interlude: “I’ll Be Home for Christmas””

  1. I don’t believe there was anything like a Christmas truce in WWII, but I do remember reading in John Toland’s book Battle: The Story of the
    Bulge about POWs being evacuated to the rear on a Sherman tank taking up Silent Night with their American captors. Seemed like an oddly warm sentiment.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I suppose, “Schtille Nacht” (I should check the spelling on that) was written in German originally… It’s odd, isn’t it, to find those stories- those sudden switches from enemy to…something else? They aren’t restricted to Christmas, either- there was a stop to shelling on both sides for Easter around Monte Cassino in Italy (1943 I THINK)

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Wonderful post, Anne! Thanks for this nostalgic recollection. I think I even have Bing Crosby’s “White Christmas” LP album in the house, dating back to my parents’ collection. 🙂 Anyway, I’ve just finished listening to the audiobook of Erik Larson’s newest “The Splendid and the Vile” and this book is a must-read (listen), about Winston Churchill during the Blitz, and lots of juicy tidbits, as well as war strategies. I’m sure you’ll find it captivating. And with this comment, I’ll send you my Christmas Wish to you and yours: Have a Blessed, Merry and Safe Christmas!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I love White Christmas- the song and the musical are favorites! (The kids have been dreaming of a real one, too, but it looks like that may require a drive to the mountains…)


  3. Bo loves playing this Bing album as well, Anne, and I can see why the powers that be would be concerned such a song could kill morale. Sometimes we all need a song that helps us dream of brighter, better, kinder places, right? 🙂 A blessed New Year to you and the Clare Clan! xxxxxx

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s